Created by Mike Flanagan, this 2021 supernatural horror TV series is set on a remote island community that experiences miraculous events and frightening omens after the arrival of a mysterious young priest. What is this chilling show called?

The chilling show described is "Midnight Mass (Review)," a supernatural horror miniseries that premiered on Netflix in 2021. It was created, directed, and largely written by Mike Flanagan, known for his distinctive approach to the horror genre. The series centers on Crockett Island, an isolated and economically struggling community, whose existing divisions are exacerbated by the arrival of a charismatic and mysterious young priest, Father Paul. His presence coincides with a series of inexplicable and seemingly miraculous events, which ignite a renewed religious fervor among the islanders.

Flanagan, a self-described "former altar boy," infused "Midnight Mass" with profound themes beyond typical scares, delving into complex discussions about faith, doubt, addiction, grief, and redemption. The show masterfully explores how miraculous events can mislead and justify harmful actions within a religious community, examining the manipulation of faith and fear. It presents a nuanced look at religion, contemplating the power it holds and how easily it can be warped into something sinister, particularly when institutionalized.

The series garnered positive reviews upon its release, with critics praising Flanagan's direction and the compelling performances of its cast, especially Hamish Linklater as Father Paul. It was lauded for its ambitious meditation on grief and faith, offering a slow-burn triumph of terror that leaves viewers contemplating long after the credits roll. "Midnight Mass" stands out as a thought-provoking entry in the horror genre, using its unsettling narrative to reflect on the broken and beautiful aspects of humanity and the church.